Currently on my second pair of these. The first developed a noticeable click in the right heel when walking (loud enough for others to notice). I returned those under warranty. The replacements had some imperfections in the leather, but not a huge deal. However, after a couple of months the click is back. Quality seems to be an issue across the board with JM as all of my shoes from them have issues ranging from clicking to rubber separating. For the price, I wouldn't buy again and would be hesitant to buy from JM again.