Casteel Plain Toe

jump to style recommendations
Casteel Plain Toe image number null
Casteel Plain Toe image number null
Casteel Plain Toe image number null
Casteel Plain Toe image number null

Casteel Plain Toe

3.1 out of 5 Customer Rating
Casteel Plain Toe
Price reduced from $299.00 to $99.99

Select Color

Color: Navy Italian Calfskin

Size Chart
8 8.5 9 9.5 10 10.5 11 11.5 12 13
M
Want It Sooner? Pickup In Store
Polaris Fashion Place
Search by Zip Code

Select Your Store

    Details

    Item 24-2157
    • Crafted in Italy.
    • Hand-finished Italian calfskin with dress shoe refinement, cushioned sport sole. 
    • Leather lining.
    • Leather welt. 
    • Flexible, lightweight EVA sole.
    Free Shipping & Returns See more See less
    Become a J&M Insider and get free shipping and free returns, all the time. Usually arrives in 4-7 days.

    Complete The Look

    Ratings & Reviews

    Reviews

    Rating Snapshot

    Select a row below to filter reviews.
    30 reviews with 5 stars.
    7 reviews with 4 stars.
    4 reviews with 3 stars.
    2 reviews with 2 stars.
    3 reviews with 1 star.

    Overall Rating

    4.3

    Review this Product

    Select to rate the item with 1 star. This action will open submission form.
    Select to rate the item with 2 stars. This action will open submission form.
    Select to rate the item with 3 stars. This action will open submission form.
    Select to rate the item with 4 stars. This action will open submission form.
    Select to rate the item with 5 stars. This action will open submission form.
    Adding a review will require a valid email for verification

    Filter Reviews

    1 to 8 of 46 Reviews
    1 – 8 of 46 Reviews

    Blister shoes

    3 years ago
    These shoes blistered my heels the first time I wore them and the second time I wore them. I then went to a shoemaker to provide a better heel backing and it didn't make a difference as the next time I wore them my heels blistered again. I could recommend these shoes to anyone. It is disappointing because I have been a Johnson Murphy customer in the past, but probably not in the future.
    Helpful?

    These shoes are great. Very

    4 years ago
    These shoes are great. Very well made. Sizing is just a tad smaller than normal, in other words they fit tight when you first get them but as you wear them they start to fit like a glove.
    Helpful?

    Wonderful Shoe!

    4 years ago
    If your are looking for a shoe that is comfortable if you're on your feet for hours or walking a lot and durable with support if you have orthopedic issues with your feet these are the shoes to buy! I purchased both the black and brown pairs. They will be slightly uncomfortable until you break them in but once you do they are amazing. They are comfortable and offer great foot support proving why Italian made shoes are so much superior!
    Helpful?

    Heavy weights and no comfort

    4 years ago
    The shoe is heavy and has no comfort and need serious design help. I wouldn’t buy it again
    Helpful?

    Great shoes!

    4 years ago
    What a great pair of shoes. They are stylish but comfortable at the same time. I wear this shoes casually all the time and to go to the office. Will recommend this shoes to everyone.
    Helpful?

    Return

    4 years ago
    Shoes were too tight and packaging was worn, appeared to be a return.
    Helpful?

    Quality

    4 years ago
    The shoes are a great quality and build. Surprisingly good for the money!!- I buy exclusively Johnston and Murphy shoes - these were cut a bit small and tighter than normal so I had to return them (sadly)- the return process was surprisingly easy- they were extremely helpful and the process was a dream
    Helpful?

    Castellated review

    4 years ago
    The shoes did feel comfortable. They did not have the J&M quality feeling.
    Helpful?