Holden Plain Toe

jump to style recommendations
Holden Plain Toe image number null
Holden Plain Toe image number null
Holden Plain Toe image number null
Holden Plain Toe image number null

Holden Plain Toe

4 out of 5 Customer Rating
Holden Plain Toe
Price reduced from $129.00 to $89.99

Select Color

Color: Tan Oiled Full Grain

Size Chart
7 7.5 8 8.5 9 9.5 10 10.5 11 11.5 12 13 14 15 16
M W
Want It Sooner? Pickup In Store
Polaris Fashion Place
1500 Polaris Fashion Pkwy.
Columbus, OH 43240
Search by Zip Code

Select Your Store

    Details

    Item 20-4906
    • Innovative construction merges classic style with ultralight, cushioned comfort. 
    • Genuine leather for a premium fit and feel.
    • Memory foam cushioning molds to foot contours. 
    • Leather/textile lining.
    • Leather welt. 
    • Shock-absorbing, flexible EVA sole.
    Free Shipping & Returns See more See less
    Become a J&M Insider and get free shipping and free returns, all the time. Usually arrives in 4-7 days.

    Pairs Well With

    Complete The Look

    1st bundle featuring 4 items which compliment Holden Plain Toe
    2nd bundle featuring 4 items which compliment Holden Plain Toe
    3rd bundle featuring 4 items which compliment Holden Plain Toe
    4th bundle featuring 4 items which compliment Holden Plain Toe
    5th bundle featuring 4 items which compliment Holden Plain Toe
    6th bundle featuring 4 items which compliment Holden Plain Toe
    7th bundle featuring 4 items which compliment Holden Plain Toe

    Ratings & Reviews

    Reviews

    Rating Snapshot

    Select a row below to filter reviews.
    415 reviews with 5 stars.
    69 reviews with 4 stars.
    52 reviews with 3 stars.
    39 reviews with 2 stars.
    63 reviews with 1 star.

    Overall Rating

    4.2

    Review this Product

    Select to rate the item with 1 star. This action will open submission form.
    Select to rate the item with 2 stars. This action will open submission form.
    Select to rate the item with 3 stars. This action will open submission form.
    Select to rate the item with 4 stars. This action will open submission form.
    Select to rate the item with 5 stars. This action will open submission form.
    Adding a review will require a valid email for verification

    Filter Reviews

    1 to 8 of 638 Reviews
    1 – 8 of 638 Reviews

    Good stuff!

    a month ago
    Love J&M shoes! I have had several pairs and will keep buying them. This shoe is no different, stylish, comfortable, and versatile! I
    Helpful?

    My new Holden Plain Toe shoes

    a month ago
    When I wear my new Holden Plain Toe shoes, I feel like a young man rather than an 85-year old man. They are so light, stylish and comfortable. They make walking a lot in Alaska even more enjoyable. The grain finish looks so good.
    Helpful?

    good as expected. Par for

    a month ago
    good as expected. Par for the course. will purchase again.
    Helpful?

    Holden Plain Toe

    2 months ago
    I've worn Johnston & Murphy shoes for years, and they consistently deliver when it comes to style and versatility. My most recent purchase—the Holden Plain Toe—looks sharp enough for the office but transitions well to more casual outings. The leather is clearly high-quality, and the design has a timeless, polished look. Comfort is another strong point. After a brief break-in period, they became one of my go-to pairs for all-day wear. The memory foam insole and overall construction offer solid support without compromising on appearance.
    Helpful?

    Great feeling shoes

    2 months ago
    I would have went up a half size to have a little room
    Helpful?

    Jose

    2 months ago
    Stylish and comfortable. One small complaint, the top line of both shoes caused blisters. Hopefully I’ll be able to break them in!
    Helpful?

    Review of shoes

    2 months ago
    I’m a big fan of Johnston and Murphy and have been shopping for years. Although you present elegant look of shoes but comfort has been on the decline. Recently bought two shoes and had to return one of them because of a tight fit despite ordering the correct size. The soak of One of them ware out so fast three months but can’t return it because I bought it more than a year ago- had i known the return policy I would have returned it on time. Look of your shoe are great but fitting and comfort, size, back rubbings of shoe is still a big issue for me. Hope you will improve. Thanks , Mathewos
    Helpful?

    Durable, classy and comfortable.

    2 months ago
    Comfortable, durable and good for nearly every occasion you can imagine. I can wear them to my outdoor job or to a dressy event. Love 'em, and have gotten this same shoe multiple times. My go-to shoe!
    Helpful?