McGuffey Plain Toe

McGuffey Plain Toe

3.4 out of 5 Customer Rating
McGuffey Plain Toe

Select Color
$99.90
Select Colors $89.99

Color: Tan Oiled Full Grain

Want It Sooner? Pickup In Store
Polaris Fashion Place
1500 Polaris Fashion Pkwy.
Columbus, OH 43240

Select Your Store

    Details

    Item 25-1642
    • Updated textures and styles add interest. 
    • Supple oiled full-grain leather or soft matte nubuck and breathable knit. 
    • Lightweight strobel construction. 
    • Skeletal leather lining. 
    • Leather/performance fabric-covered cushioned insole.
    Free Shipping & Returns See more See less
    Become a J&M Insider and get free shipping and free returns, all the time. Usually arrives in 4-7 days.

    Complete The Look

    Ratings & Reviews

    Reviews

    Rating Snapshot

    Select a row below to filter reviews.
    585 reviews with 5 stars.
    101 reviews with 4 stars.
    49 reviews with 3 stars.
    30 reviews with 2 stars.
    47 reviews with 1 star.

    Overall Rating

    4.4

    Review this Product

    Select to rate the item with 1 star. This action will open submission form.
    Select to rate the item with 2 stars. This action will open submission form.
    Select to rate the item with 3 stars. This action will open submission form.
    Select to rate the item with 4 stars. This action will open submission form.
    Select to rate the item with 5 stars. This action will open submission form.
    Adding a review will require a valid email for verification

    Filter Reviews

    1 to 8 of 812 Reviews
    1 – 8 of 812 Reviews

    Shoes got that "worn in"

    2 months ago
    Shoes got that "worn in" look quickly. Great with casual pants!
    Helpful?

    Great Shoe

    2 months ago
    A very classy shoe for work and casual attire. Very comfortable to walk long distances in. I wish the sole on the outside could be darker, which is my only knock
    Helpful?

    Great Customer Service

    2 months ago
    The shoes I ordered did not fit as well as all of my other J&M shoes but I liked the style. I called Customer Service. I was treated very courteously and professionally. The representative listened to my problem and guided me through the return process. I was very impressed. I will continue to be a loyal J&M customer.
    Helpful?

    Great Shoes

    2 months ago
    These are very comfortable and stylish. The leather is so soft too. Great shoes. Glad I got them
    Helpful?

    Nice, Clean Design

    2 months ago
    Nice shoe with a clean design, fits about a 1/2 size larger than other shoe's I've worn from J&M before. I'm usually a 10. 5, but wear an 11 in these.
    Helpful?

    new shoes

    3 months ago
    These feel great and are the correct size I got 12w
    Helpful?

    Johnston & Murphy are by

    3 months ago
    Johnston & Murphy are by far the most comfortable casual dress shoes I own, have many pairs, and these McGuffey Plain Toe did not disappoint at all!! Great shoes!
    Helpful?

    My second pair, great shoe!

    3 months ago
    I love this shoe, it is my second pair. I considered getting the newer version but couldn't pass up the sale price.
    Helpful?