Images

McGuffey Plain Toe
McGuffey Plain Toe
McGuffey Plain Toe
Click to Rotate

McGuffey Plain Toe

McGuffey Plain Toe

Details

  • $129.00
    Select Colors $99.99
    Select Colors $99.90
  • ColorNavy Oiled Full Grain
  • Size 10
  • Width M

Add to cart options

Product Actions

What's an eGift?

 

Not quite sure of their style or size? No problem! All you need is their email address to instantly email this item as a gift. Your recipient will pick their size and color before we ship the item. If it's not quite their style, they can simply choose a gift card for the same amount.

 

eGift FAQ

State/Province
or Zip Code
Within
Submit

Additional Information

DETAILS

Item
  • Updated textures and styles add interest. 
  • Supple oiled full-grain leather or soft matte nubuck and breathable knit. 
  • Lightweight strobel construction. 
  • Skeletal leather lining. 
  • Leather/performance fabric-covered cushioned insole.
Free Shipping & Returns See more See less
Free ground shipping on orders over $100 and free returns, all the time. Usually arrives in 4-7 business days. Each order comes with a prepaid return label for free returns by mail, or items may be returned or exchanged at any Johnston & Murphy store, free of charge.

Show Us Your Style Show Us Your Style

RATINGS AND REVIEWS

<div class="main-widget yotpo-display-wrapper " style="visibility: hidden;"> <div class="yotpo-label yotpo-small-box "> <a href="http://my.yotpo.com/landing_page?redirect=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.yotpo.com%2Fpowered-by-yotpo%2F&utm_campaign=branding_link_reviews_widget_v2&utm_medium=widget&utm_source=johnstonmurphy.com" class="yotpo-logo-link-new" aria-label="Yotpo Home Page" tabindex="0" target="_blank"> <span class="yotpo-logo-title "> Powered by </span> <div class="yotpo-icon-btn-big transparent-color-btn yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-yotpo-logo yotpo-logo-icon-new yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-yotpo-logo "> </div> </a> <div class="yotpo-default-button yotpo-icon-btn pull-right yotpo-hidden-mobile write-button write-review-button" role="button" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-write"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon-button-text">write a review</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-logo-line"> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> <span class="yotpo-display-wrapper" style="visibility: hidden;"> <div class="yotpo-regular-box yotpo-bottomline yotpo-bottomline-3-boxes "> <div class="yotpo-bottomline-box-1 yotpo-stars-and-sum-reviews"> <span class="yotpo-stars"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-half-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="sr-only">4.6 star rating</span> </span> <span class="yotpo-sum-reviews" style=""> <span class="font-color-gray based-on">307 Reviews</span> </span> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-bottomline-box-2"> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution"> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-content"> <div class="yotpo-distibutions-stars"> <span class="review-stars yotpo-distribution-clickable" data-score-distribution="5"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star pull-left"></span> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </span> <span class="review-stars yotpo-distribution-clickable" data-score-distribution="4"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star pull-left"></span> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </span> <span class="review-stars yotpo-distribution-clickable" data-score-distribution="3"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star pull-left"></span> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </span> <span class="review-stars yotpo-distribution-clickable" data-score-distribution="2"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star pull-left"></span> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </span> <span class="review-stars yotpo-distribution-clickable" data-score-distribution="1"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star pull-left"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star pull-left"></span> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </span> </div> <div class="yotpo-distibutions-sum-reviews"> <span class="yotpo-sum-reviews text-xs font-color-primary yotpo-distribution-clickable" role=button tabindex=0 data-score-distribution="5">(231)</span> <span class="yotpo-sum-reviews text-xs font-color-primary yotpo-distribution-clickable" role=button tabindex=0 data-score-distribution="4">(50)</span> <span class="yotpo-sum-reviews text-xs font-color-primary yotpo-distribution-clickable" role=button tabindex=0 data-score-distribution="3">(10)</span> <span class="yotpo-sum-reviews text-xs font-color-primary yotpo-distribution-clickable" role=button tabindex=0 data-score-distribution="2">(5)</span> <span class="yotpo-sum-reviews text-xs font-color-primary yotpo-distribution-clickable" role=button tabindex=0 data-score-distribution="1">(11)</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-distributions-graphs"> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-graph yotpo-distribution-clickable" data-score-distribution="5"> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-graph-background"></div> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-score-wrapper"> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-graph-score" style="width: 75.2442996742671%;"></div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-graph yotpo-distribution-clickable" data-score-distribution="4"> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-graph-background"></div> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-score-wrapper"> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-graph-score" style="width: 16.286644951140065%;"></div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-graph yotpo-distribution-clickable" data-score-distribution="3"> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-graph-background"></div> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-score-wrapper"> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-graph-score" style="width: 3.257328990228013%;"></div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-graph yotpo-distribution-clickable" data-score-distribution="2"> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-graph-background"></div> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-score-wrapper"> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-graph-score" style="width: 1.6286644951140066%;"></div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-graph yotpo-distribution-clickable" data-score-distribution="1"> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-graph-background"></div> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-score-wrapper"> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-graph-score" style="width: 3.5830618892508146%;"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <div class="yotpo-star-distribution-footer text-xs yotpo-hidden"> <span class="yotpo-star-distribution-show-all">Show all reviews</span> </div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </span> <form> <div class="write-review-wrapper write-form"> <div class="write-review yotpo-regular-box"> <div class="yotpo-header"> <div> <span class="y-label yotpo-header-title">WRITE A REVIEW</span> </div> <span class="y-label">Score:</span> <div> <span class="stars-wrapper"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star pull-left review-star" data-score="1" aria-label="score 1" role="button" tabindex="0"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star pull-left review-star" data-score="2" aria-label="score 2" role="button" tabindex="0"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star pull-left review-star" data-score="3" aria-label="score 3" role="button" tabindex="0"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star pull-left review-star" data-score="4" aria-label="score 4" role="button" tabindex="0"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star pull-left review-star" data-score="5" aria-label="score 5" role="button" tabindex="0"></span> </span> </div> </div> <div class="write-review-content"> <div class="form-group" data-custom-form-id=17948> <div class="form-element"> <label class="y-label" for="yotpo_input_review_title"> <span class="yotpo-mandatory-mark">* </span> Title: </label> <input id="yotpo_input_review_title" class="y-input" autocomplete="off" name="review_title" maxlength="150" placeholder=""/> </div> <div class="form-element"> <label class="y-label" for="yotpo_input_review_content"> <span class="yotpo-mandatory-mark">* </span> Review: </label> <textarea id="yotpo_input_review_content" class="y-input yotpo-text-box" name="review_content" placeholder=""></textarea> </div> <div class="form-element yotpo-custom-tag-field "> <span class="y-label yotpo-field-title"> Would you recommend this item to a friend? </span> <div class="yotpo-single-choice-field"> <fieldset> <legend>Would you recommend this item to a friend?</legend> <div class="yotpo-single-choice-option"> <div class="yotpo-radio-wrapper"><input id="yotpo_input_single_choice_would_you_recommend_this_item_to_a_friend_1" type="radio" name="--23748" value="Yes"></div> <label for="yotpo_input_single_choice_would_you_recommend_this_item_to_a_friend_1" class="y-label yotpo-field-option-label">Yes</label> </div> <div class="yotpo-single-choice-option"> <div class="yotpo-radio-wrapper"><input id="yotpo_input_single_choice_would_you_recommend_this_item_to_a_friend_2" type="radio" name="--23748" value="No"></div> <label for="yotpo_input_single_choice_would_you_recommend_this_item_to_a_friend_2" class="y-label yotpo-field-option-label">No</label> </div> </fieldset> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-footer yotpo-animation-opacity"> <div class="socialize-wrapper"> <div class="connected">You are connected as <span class="username"></span></div> <div class="socialize"> <span class="y-label">Connect with:</span> <div> <div class="yotpo-default-button yotpo-icon-btn" data-network="linkedin" aria-label="connect with linkedIn" role="link" tabindex="0"><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-linkedin pull-left"></span></div> <div class="yotpo-default-button yotpo-icon-btn" data-network="twitter" aria-label="connect with twitter" role="link" tabindex="0"><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-twitter pull-left"></span></div> <div class="yotpo-default-button yotpo-icon-btn" data-network="facebook" aria-label="connect with facebook" role="link" tabindex="0"><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-facebook pull-left"></span></div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-or"> -OR- </div> </div> <div class="connect-wrapper "> <div class="form-element name-input"> <label class="y-label" for="yotpo_input_review_username">Use your name:</label> <input id="yotpo_input_review_username" class="y-input" autocomplete="off" name="display_name" maxlength="40" placeholder=""/> </div> <div class="form-element email-input"> <label class="y-label" for="yotpo_input_review_email">Email:</label> <input id="yotpo_input_review_email" class="y-input" autocomplete="off" name="email" placeholder=""/> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </div> <div class="error-box yotpo-hidden"> <div class="text-wrapper"> <span class="error-text empty yotpo-hidden">Review&#39;s title &amp; body can&#39;t be empty</span> <span class="error-text score yotpo-hidden">Please enter a star rating for this review</span> <span class="error-text display_name_empty yotpo-hidden">Name field cannot be empty</span> <span class="error-text email yotpo-hidden">Invalid email</span> <span class="error-text user-already-reviewed yotpo-hidden">Your review has already been submitted.</span> <span class="error-text max_length yotpo-hidden">Max length was exceeded</span> <span class="error-text mandatory_field yotpo-hidden">Please fill out all of the mandatory (*) fields</span> <span class="error-text open_question_answer_length yotpo-hidden">One or more of your answers does not meet the required criteria</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-icon-btn-small transparent-color-btn"><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-cross"></span></div> </div> <input type="button" class="yotpo-default-button primary-color-btn yotpo-submit yotpo-disabled" data-button-type="submit" value="Post"/> <div class="yotpo-preloader-wrapper"> <div class="yotpo yotpo-pre-loader"> <span class="yotpo-empty-stars"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star"></span> </span> <span class="yotpo-full-stars"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star"></span> </span> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </div> </form> <div class="yotpo-messages"> <div class="yotpo-thank-you yotpo-hidden" data-type="share"> <div class="yotpo-icon-btn transparent-color-btn"><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-cross"></span></div> <div class="yotpo-thankyou-header text-3xl"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-heart"></span> <span>Thank you for posting a review!</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-thankyou-content"> <span>We value your input. Share your review so everyone else can enjoy it too.</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-thankyou-footer"> <div class="yotpo-default-button yotpo-icon-btn"> <a class="social-link popup-link" href="#" target="_blank" data-network="facebook"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-facebook"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon-button-text">share</span> </a> </div> <div class="yotpo-default-button yotpo-icon-btn"> <a class="social-link popup-link" href="#" target="_blank" data-network="twitter"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-twitter"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon-button-text">share</span> </a> </div> <div class="yotpo-default-button yotpo-icon-btn"> <a class="social-link popup-link" href="#" target="_blank" data-network="linkedin"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-linkedin"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon-button-text">share</span> </a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-thank-you yotpo-hidden" data-type="pending-for-review-approval"> <div class="yotpo-icon-btn transparent-color-btn"><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-cross"></span></div> <div class="yotpo-thankyou-header text-3xl"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-heart"></span> <span>Thank you for posting a review!</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-thankyou-content"> <span>Your review was sent successfully and is now waiting for our staff to publish it.</span> </div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-small-box yotpo-nav reviews 0"> <div class="yotpo-nav yotpo-nav-primary" role="tablist"> <ul> <li class="yotpo-nav-tab yotpo-active" data-type="reviews" data-content="yotpo-reviews-4975541e-8f83-471c-8641-55a398f2e50a yotpo-reviews-header-4975541e-8f83-471c-8641-55a398f2e50a yotpo-reviews-filters-4975541e-8f83-471c-8641-55a398f2e50a" role="tab" tabindex="0"> <div class="yotpo-nav-wrapper"> <span>Reviews</span> <span class="nav-tab-sum yotpo-reviews-nav-tab-sum">(307)</span> </div> </li> </ul> <div class="yotpo-icon-btn-big transparent-color-btn yotpo-visible-mobile"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-three-lines"></span> </div> <div class="yotpo-dropdown-wrapper mobile-collapse"> <div class="yotpo-menu-mobile-collapse yotpo-hidden-mobile"> <div class="yotpo-nav-dropdown-category yotpo-visible-mobile write-review-button" role="button" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-write"></span> <span class="y-label">write a review</span> </div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-nav-content"> <div class="search-in-progress"> <div class="search-in-progress-text font-color-gray"> Updating Results </div> <div class="yotpo-spinner"> <div class="sk-spinner sk-spinner-three-bounce"> <div class="sk-bounce1"></div> <div class="sk-bounce2"></div> <div class="sk-bounce3"></div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-reviews yotpo-active" id="yotpo-reviews-4975541e-8f83-471c-8641-55a398f2e50a" data-host-widget="main_widget"> <div class="yotpo-preloader-wrapper"> <div class="yotpo yotpo-pre-loader"> <span class="yotpo-empty-stars"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star"></span> </span> <span class="yotpo-full-stars"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star"></span> </span> </div> </div> <div class="total-reviews-search" total-reviews-search="307"></div> <div class="yotpo-review yotpo-regular-box " data-review-id="126130464"> <div class="yotpo-header yotpo-verified-buyer "> <span class="yotpo-icon-profile yotpo-header-element pull-left"> <span class="yotpo-user-letter">W</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-circle-checkmark yotpo-action-hover" data-type="toggleFade" data-target="yotpo-tool-tip" data-target-container="yotpo-header"></span> </span> <div class="yotpo-header-element "> <span class="y-label yotpo-user-name yotpo-font-bold pull-left">William H.</span> <div class="label-with-tooltip pull-left"> <span class="y-label yotpo-user-title yotpo-action-hover" data-type="toggleFade" data-target="yotpo-tool-tip">Verified Buyer</span> <div class="yotpo-tool-tip yotpo-animation-fade" data-user-type="yotpo-verified-buyer"> <div class="tool-tip-container"> <div class="x-button-for-touch-screens"><button class="pull-right" aria-label="Close"><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-cross"></span></button></div> <div class="tool-tip-header"> <span>What is a</span> <span class="header-green">Verified Buyer</span> </div> <div class="tool-tip-content"> A Verified Buyer is a user who has purchased the reviewed product through our store. </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <span class="yotpo-review-stars "> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="sr-only">4 star rating</span> </span> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-header-element yotpo-header-actions "> <span class="y-label yotpo-review-date">09/23/19</span> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-main "> <div class="content-title yotpo-font-bold"> The outside leather between the </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <div class="yotpo-review-wrapper"> <div class="content-review"> The outside leather between the arch and heel is not smooth because the stitching gathers it up. </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-review-images-wrapper"> <img alt="" class="image-review" data-original-src="//cdn-yotpo-images-production.yotpo.com/Review/126130464/95739076/original.jpg?1569244616" data-image-id="95739076" src="//cdn-yotpo-images-production.yotpo.com/Review/126130464/95739076/square.jpg?1569244616" /> <img alt="" class="image-review" data-original-src="//cdn-yotpo-images-production.yotpo.com/Review/126130464/95739080/original.jpg?1569244624" data-image-id="95739080" src="//cdn-yotpo-images-production.yotpo.com/Review/126130464/95739080/square.jpg?1569244624" /> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <a class="product-link-wrapper yotpo-hidden" aria-label="Product McGuffey Plain Toe" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1" href="https://yotpo.com/go/fNbuybH9" target="_blank" rel="nofollow"> <div data-product-id="118168366" class="y-label product-link"> On McGuffey Plain Toe </div> </a> </div> <div class="yotpo-footer "> <div class="footer-actions"> <span class="yotpo-action" data-type="toggleFade" data-target="share-review" aria-labelledby="review-126130464" role="button" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-share"></span> <span class="y-label">share</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-seperator"></span> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="review-126130464">' Share Review by William H. on 23 Sep 2019 </span> <span class="share-options-wrapper"> <span class="share-options share-review"> <span data-social="facebook"> <span class="y-label yotpo-action"> <a class="social-link popup-link" data-network="facebook" href="https://www.facebook.com/dialog/feed?app_id=226132034107547&aria_labelled_by=facebook-review-126130464&display=popup&link=http%3A%2F%2Freviews.me%2Ffacebook_post%3Fimage_url%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fcdn-yotpo-images-production.yotpo.com%252FProduct%252F118168366%252F94902388%252Ffacebook.jpg%253F1581189408%26product_url%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fyotpo.com%252Fgo%252FqfvqcdSn%26review%3DThe%2Boutside%2Bleather%2Bbetween%2Bthe%2Barch%2Band%2Bheel%2Bis%2Bnot%2Bsmooth%2Bbecause%2Bthe%2Bstitching%2Bgathers%2Bit%2Bup.%26social_title%3DThe%2Boutside%2Bleather%2Bbetween%2Bthe&redirect_uri=http%3A%2F%2Fmy.yotpo.com%2Fshares%3Freview_id%3D126130464"><i class="facebook share" aria-labelledby="facebook-review-126130464">facebook</i></a> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="facebook-review-126130464">facebook Share Review by William H. on 23 Sep 2019</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-dot"></span> </span> <span data-social="twitter"> <span class="y-label yotpo-action"> <a class="social-link popup-link" data-network="twitter" href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?aria_labelled_by=twitter-review-126130464&text=The+outside+leather+between+the+arch+and+heel+is+not+smooth+because+the+stitching+gathers+it+up.&url=https%3A%2F%2Fyotpo.com%2Fgo%2Fcs2QRYTq&via=yotpo"><i class="twitter share" aria-labelledby="twitter-review-126130464">twitter</i></a> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="twitter-review-126130464">twitter Share Review by William H. on 23 Sep 2019</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-dot"></span> </span> <span data-social="linkedin"> <span class="y-label yotpo-action"> <a class="social-link popup-link" data-network="LinkedIn" href="https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?aria_labelled_by=linkedin-review-126130464&mini=true&source=Yotpo&summary=The+outside+leather+between+the+arch+and+heel+is+not+smooth+because+the+stitching+gathers+it+up.&title=The+outside+leather+between+the&url=https%3A%2F%2Fyotpo.com%2Fgo%2Fk7hKdLFh"><i class="LinkedIn share" aria-labelledby="linkedin-review-126130464">LinkedIn</i></a> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="linkedin-review-126130464">linkedin Share Review by William H. on 23 Sep 2019</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-separator"></span> </span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-seperator"></span> </span> </span> </div> <div class="yotpo-helpful"> <span class="y-label label-helpful">Was this review helpful?</span> <div class="yotpo-icon-btn-small transparent-color-btn vote-btn" data-type="up" role="button" aria-label="vote up Review by William H. on 23 Sep 2019" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-thumbs-up"></span> </div> <span class="y-label yotpo-sum vote-sum" data-type="up">1</span> <div class="yotpo-icon-btn-small transparent-color-btn vote-btn" data-type="down" role="button" aria-label="vote down Review by William H. on 23 Sep 2019" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-thumbs-down"></span> </div> <span class="y-label yotpo-sum vote-sum" data-type="down">0</span> </div> <div class="footer-additional-actions"> <span class="y-label yotpo-review-date">09/23/19</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <div class="yotpo-grouping-reference"> <span class="yotpo-attribution-indicator">Reviewed on:</span> <a href="https://yotpo.com/go/pThWfvDD" target="_blank" class="grouping-reference-link" rel="nofollow">McGuffey Plain Toe</a> </div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-review yotpo-regular-box " data-review-id="148529976"> <div class="yotpo-header "> <span class="yotpo-icon-profile yotpo-header-element pull-left"> <span class="yotpo-user-letter">M</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-circle-checkmark yotpo-action-hover" data-type="toggleFade" data-target="yotpo-tool-tip" data-target-container="yotpo-header"></span> </span> <div class="yotpo-header-element "> <span class="y-label yotpo-user-name yotpo-font-bold pull-left">Mathias F.</span> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <span class="yotpo-review-stars "> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="sr-only">1 star rating</span> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <div class="yotpo-user-related-fields"> <div class="yotpo-user-field" data-type=SingleChoice> <span class="yotpo-user-field-description text-s">Bottom Line:</span> <span class="yotpo-user-field-answer text-s">No</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </span> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-header-element yotpo-header-actions "> <span class="y-label yotpo-review-date">02/08/20</span> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-main "> <div class="yotpo-multiple-rating-fields"> <div class="yotpo-user-related-fields"> <div class="yotpo-user-field" data-type=SingleChoice> <span class="yotpo-user-field-description text-s">Bottom Line:</span> <span class="yotpo-user-field-answer text-s">No</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </div> <div class="content-title yotpo-font-bold"> 2 pairs - both noisy </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <div class="yotpo-review-wrapper"> <div class="content-review"> Bought these shoes twice. After 3 months the first pair started squeaking, both shoes around the same time. A squeak with each step. Maddening. I am not one who often returns things, so I assumed maybe I just got a bad pair and bought a new pair, exact same style and size. Within a month the right shoe started squeaking just like the first pair. My wife insisted I take them back, which I did. They were helpful at the store, and allowed me to return them and apply the price towards a new pair, but something is going on with the quality of these shoes. I don't have this issue with any other shoes or sneakers. </div> </div> <a class="product-link-wrapper " aria-label="Product McGuffey Plain Toe" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1" href="https://yotpo.com/go/fNbuybH9" target="_blank" rel="nofollow"> <div data-product-id="118168366" class="y-label product-link"> On McGuffey Plain Toe </div> </a> </div> <div class="yotpo-footer "> <div class="footer-actions"> <span class="yotpo-action" data-type="toggleFade" data-target="share-review" aria-labelledby="review-148529976" role="button" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-share"></span> <span class="y-label">share</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-seperator"></span> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="review-148529976">' Share Review by Mathias F. on 8 Feb 2020 </span> <span class="share-options-wrapper"> <span class="share-options share-review"> <span data-social="facebook"> <span class="y-label yotpo-action"> <a class="social-link popup-link" data-network="facebook" href="https://www.facebook.com/dialog/feed?app_id=226132034107547&aria_labelled_by=facebook-review-148529976&display=popup&link=http%3A%2F%2Freviews.me%2Ffacebook_post%3Fimage_url%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fcdn-yotpo-images-production.yotpo.com%252FProduct%252F118168366%252F94902388%252Ffacebook.jpg%253F1581189408%26product_url%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fyotpo.com%252Fgo%252FqfvqcdSn%26review%3DBought%2Bthese%2Bshoes%2Btwice.%2BAfter%2B3%2Bmonths%2Bthe%2Bfirst%2Bpair%2Bstarted%2Bsqueaking%252C%2Bboth%2Bshoes%2Baround%2Bthe%2Bsame%2Btime.%2BA%2Bsqueak%2Bwith%2Beach%2Bstep.%2BMaddening.%2BI%2Bam%2Bnot%2Bone%2Bwho%2Boften%2Breturns%2Bthings%252C%2Bso%2BI%2Bassumed%2Bmaybe%2BI%2Bjust%2Bgot%2Ba%2Bbad%2Bpair%2Band%2Bbought%2Ba%2Bnew%2Bpair%252C%2Bexact%2Bsame%2Bstyle%2Band%2Bsize.%2BWithin%2Ba%2Bmonth%2Bthe%2Bright%2Bshoe%2Bstarted%2Bsqueaking%2Bjust%2Blike%2Bthe%2Bfirst%2Bpair.%2BMy%2Bwife%2Binsisted%2BI%2Btake%2Bthem%2Bback%252C%2Bwhich%2BI%2Bdid.%2BThey%2Bwere%2Bhelpful%2Bat%2Bthe%2Bstore%252C%2Band%2Ballowed%2Bme%2Bto%2Breturn%2Bthem%2Band%2Bapply%2Bthe%2Bprice%2Btowards%2Ba%2Bnew%2Bpair%252C%2Bbut%2Bsomething%2Bis%2Bgoing%2Bon%2Bwith%2Bthe%2Bquality%2Bof%2Bthese%2Bshoes.%2BI%2Bdon%2527t%2Bhave%2Bthis%2Bissue%2Bwith%2Bany%2Bother%2Bshoes%2Bor%2Bsneakers.%26social_title%3D2%2Bpairs%2B-%2Bboth%2Bnoisy&redirect_uri=http%3A%2F%2Fmy.yotpo.com%2Fshares%3Freview_id%3D148529976"><i class="facebook share" aria-labelledby="facebook-review-148529976">facebook</i></a> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="facebook-review-148529976">facebook Share Review by Mathias F. on 8 Feb 2020</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-dot"></span> </span> <span data-social="twitter"> <span class="y-label yotpo-action"> <a class="social-link popup-link" data-network="twitter" href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?aria_labelled_by=twitter-review-148529976&text=Bought+these+shoes+twice.+After+3+months+the+first+pair+started+squeaking%2C+both+shoes+around+the+same+time.+A+squeak+with+each+step.+Maddening.+I+am+not+one+who+often+returns+things%2C+so+I+assumed+maybe+I+just+got+a+bad+pair+and+bought+a+new+pair%2C+exact+same+style+and+size.+Within+a+month+the+right+shoe+started+squeaking+just+like+the+first+pair.+My+wife+insisted+I+take+them+back%2C+which+I+did.+They+were+helpful+at+the+store%2C+and+allowed+me+to+return+them+and+apply+the+price+towards+a+new+pair%2C+but+something+is+going+on+with+the+quality+of+these+shoes.+I+don%27t+have+this+issue+with+any+other+shoes+or+sneakers.&url=https%3A%2F%2Fyotpo.com%2Fgo%2Fcs2QRYTq&via=yotpo"><i class="twitter share" aria-labelledby="twitter-review-148529976">twitter</i></a> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="twitter-review-148529976">twitter Share Review by Mathias F. on 8 Feb 2020</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-dot"></span> </span> <span data-social="linkedin"> <span class="y-label yotpo-action"> <a class="social-link popup-link" data-network="LinkedIn" href="https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?aria_labelled_by=linkedin-review-148529976&mini=true&source=Yotpo&summary=Bought+these+shoes+twice.+After+3+months+the+first+pair+started+squeaking%2C+both+shoes+around+the+same+time.+A+squeak+with+each+step.+Maddening.+I+am+not+one+who+often+returns+things%2C+so+I+assumed+maybe+I+just+got+a+bad+pair+and+bought+a+new+pair%2C+exact+same+style+and+size.+Within+a+month+the+right+shoe+started+squeaking+just+like+the+first+pair.+My+wife+insisted+I+take+them+back%2C+which+I+did.+They+were+helpful+at+the+store%2C+and+allowed+me+to+return+them+and+apply+the+price+towards+a+new+pair%2C+but+something+is+going+on+with+the+quality+of+these+shoes.+I+don%27t+have+this+issue+with+any+other+shoes+or+sneakers.&title=2+pairs+-+both+noisy&url=https%3A%2F%2Fyotpo.com%2Fgo%2Fk7hKdLFh"><i class="LinkedIn share" aria-labelledby="linkedin-review-148529976">LinkedIn</i></a> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="linkedin-review-148529976">linkedin Share Review by Mathias F. on 8 Feb 2020</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-separator"></span> </span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-seperator"></span> </span> </span> </div> <div class="yotpo-helpful"> <span class="y-label label-helpful">Was this review helpful?</span> <div class="yotpo-icon-btn-small transparent-color-btn vote-btn" data-type="up" role="button" aria-label="vote up Review by Mathias F. on 8 Feb 2020" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-thumbs-up"></span> </div> <span class="y-label yotpo-sum vote-sum" data-type="up">0</span> <div class="yotpo-icon-btn-small transparent-color-btn vote-btn" data-type="down" role="button" aria-label="vote down Review by Mathias F. on 8 Feb 2020" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-thumbs-down"></span> </div> <span class="y-label yotpo-sum vote-sum" data-type="down">0</span> </div> <div class="footer-additional-actions"> <span class="y-label yotpo-review-date">02/08/20</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-review yotpo-regular-box " data-review-id="138222882"> <div class="yotpo-header yotpo-verified-user "> <span class="yotpo-icon-profile yotpo-header-element pull-left"> <span class="yotpo-user-letter">V</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-circle-checkmark yotpo-action-hover" data-type="toggleFade" data-target="yotpo-tool-tip" data-target-container="yotpo-header"></span> </span> <div class="yotpo-header-element "> <span class="y-label yotpo-user-name yotpo-font-bold pull-left">VS N.</span> <div class="label-with-tooltip pull-left"> <span class="y-label yotpo-user-title yotpo-action-hover" data-type="toggleFade" data-target="yotpo-tool-tip">Verified Reviewer</span> <div class="yotpo-tool-tip yotpo-animation-fade" data-user-type="yotpo-verified-user"> <div class="tool-tip-container"> <div class="x-button-for-touch-screens"><button class="pull-right" aria-label="Close"><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-cross"></span></button></div> <div class="tool-tip-header"> <span>What is a</span> <span class="header-blue">Verified Reviewer</span> </div> <div class="tool-tip-content"> A Verified Reviewer is a shopper who has confirmed an email address, or connected a social network with Yotpo, providing an added level of transparency and trust. </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <span class="yotpo-review-stars "> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="sr-only">5 star rating</span> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <div class="yotpo-user-related-fields"> <div class="yotpo-user-field" data-type=SingleChoice> <span class="yotpo-user-field-description text-s">Bottom Line:</span> <span class="yotpo-user-field-answer text-s">Yes</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </span> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-header-element yotpo-header-actions "> <span class="y-label yotpo-review-date">11/20/19</span> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-main "> <div class="yotpo-multiple-rating-fields"> <div class="yotpo-user-related-fields"> <div class="yotpo-user-field" data-type=SingleChoice> <span class="yotpo-user-field-description text-s">Bottom Line:</span> <span class="yotpo-user-field-answer text-s">Yes</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </div> <div class="content-title yotpo-font-bold"> Great Shoes! </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <div class="yotpo-review-wrapper"> <div class="content-review"> Have worn Johnston and Murphy dress shoes for 20+ years but purchased these about 4 years ago and they've become my preferred shoe for daily office wear. On the days when I still wear traditional dress shoes, my feet tell me they'd rather be in the McGuffeys. Purchased a second pair for variety. Am frequently asked about them. Exceptionally comfortable. High quality. Work well with dress slacks, chinos or jeans. J&amp;M sells an easy to apply &quot;Oil Tanned Leather Restorer&quot; which returns the finish of an upper showing some wear to a nearly new look. Recommend these without reservation. </div> </div> <a class="product-link-wrapper " aria-label="Product McGuffey Plain Toe" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1" href="https://yotpo.com/go/fNbuybH9" target="_blank" rel="nofollow"> <div data-product-id="118168366" class="y-label product-link"> On McGuffey Plain Toe </div> </a> </div> <div class="yotpo-footer "> <div class="footer-actions"> <span class="yotpo-action" data-type="toggleFade" data-target="share-review" aria-labelledby="review-138222882" role="button" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-share"></span> <span class="y-label">share</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-seperator"></span> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="review-138222882">' Share Review by VS N. on 20 Nov 2019 </span> <span class="share-options-wrapper"> <span class="share-options share-review"> <span data-social="facebook"> <span class="y-label yotpo-action"> <a class="social-link popup-link" data-network="facebook" href="https://www.facebook.com/dialog/feed?app_id=226132034107547&aria_labelled_by=facebook-review-138222882&display=popup&link=http%3A%2F%2Freviews.me%2Ffacebook_post%3Fimage_url%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fcdn-yotpo-images-production.yotpo.com%252FProduct%252F118168366%252F94902388%252Ffacebook.jpg%253F1581189408%26product_url%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fyotpo.com%252Fgo%252FqfvqcdSn%26review%3DHave%2Bworn%2BJohnston%2Band%2BMurphy%2Bdress%2Bshoes%2Bfor%2B20%252B%2Byears%2Bbut%2Bpurchased%2Bthese%2Babout%2B4%2Byears%2Bago%2Band%2Bthey%2527ve%2Bbecome%2Bmy%2Bpreferred%2Bshoe%2Bfor%2Bdaily%2Boffice%2Bwear.%2BOn%2Bthe%2Bdays%2Bwhen%2BI%2Bstill%2Bwear%2Btraditional%2Bdress%2Bshoes%252C%2Bmy%2Bfeet%2Btell%2Bme%2Bthey%2527d%2Brather%2Bbe%2Bin%2Bthe%2BMcGuffeys.%2BPurchased%2Ba%2Bsecond%2Bpair%2Bfor%2Bvariety.%2BAm%2Bfrequently%2Basked%2Babout%2Bthem.%2BExceptionally%2Bcomfortable.%2BHigh%2Bquality.%2BWork%2Bwell%2Bwith%2Bdress%2Bslacks%252C%2Bchinos%2Bor%2Bjeans.%2BJ%2526M%2Bsells%2Ban%2Beasy%2Bto%2Bapply%2B%2522Oil%2BTanned%2BLeather%2BRestorer%2522%2Bwhich%2Breturns%2Bthe%2Bfinish%2Bof%2Ban%2Bupper%2Bshowing%2Bsome%2Bwear%2Bto%2Ba%2Bnearly%2Bnew%2Blook.%2BRecommend%2Bthese%2Bwithout%2Breservation.%26social_title%3DGreat%2BShoes%2521&redirect_uri=http%3A%2F%2Fmy.yotpo.com%2Fshares%3Freview_id%3D138222882"><i class="facebook share" aria-labelledby="facebook-review-138222882">facebook</i></a> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="facebook-review-138222882">facebook Share Review by VS N. on 20 Nov 2019</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-dot"></span> </span> <span data-social="twitter"> <span class="y-label yotpo-action"> <a class="social-link popup-link" data-network="twitter" href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?aria_labelled_by=twitter-review-138222882&text=Have+worn+Johnston+and+Murphy+dress+shoes+for+20%2B+years+but+purchased+these+about+4+years+ago+and+they%27ve+become+my+preferred+shoe+for+daily+office+wear.+On+the+days+when+I+still+wear+traditional+dress+shoes%2C+my+feet+tell+me+they%27d+rather+be+in+the+McGuffeys.+Purchased+a+second+pair+for+variety.+Am+frequently+asked+about+them.+Exceptionally+comfortable.+High+quality.+Work+well+with+dress+slacks%2C+chinos+or+jeans.+J%26M+sells+an+easy+to+apply+%22Oil+Tanned+Leather+Restorer%22+which+returns+the+finish+of+an+upper+showing+some+wear+to+a+nearly+new+look.+Recommend+these+without+reservation.&url=https%3A%2F%2Fyotpo.com%2Fgo%2Fcs2QRYTq&via=yotpo"><i class="twitter share" aria-labelledby="twitter-review-138222882">twitter</i></a> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="twitter-review-138222882">twitter Share Review by VS N. on 20 Nov 2019</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-dot"></span> </span> <span data-social="linkedin"> <span class="y-label yotpo-action"> <a class="social-link popup-link" data-network="LinkedIn" href="https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?aria_labelled_by=linkedin-review-138222882&mini=true&source=Yotpo&summary=Have+worn+Johnston+and+Murphy+dress+shoes+for+20%2B+years+but+purchased+these+about+4+years+ago+and+they%27ve+become+my+preferred+shoe+for+daily+office+wear.+On+the+days+when+I+still+wear+traditional+dress+shoes%2C+my+feet+tell+me+they%27d+rather+be+in+the+McGuffeys.+Purchased+a+second+pair+for+variety.+Am+frequently+asked+about+them.+Exceptionally+comfortable.+High+quality.+Work+well+with+dress+slacks%2C+chinos+or+jeans.+J%26M+sells+an+easy+to+apply+%22Oil+Tanned+Leather+Restorer%22+which+returns+the+finish+of+an+upper+showing+some+wear+to+a+nearly+new+look.+Recommend+these+without+reservation.&title=Great+Shoes%21&url=https%3A%2F%2Fyotpo.com%2Fgo%2Fk7hKdLFh"><i class="LinkedIn share" aria-labelledby="linkedin-review-138222882">LinkedIn</i></a> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="linkedin-review-138222882">linkedin Share Review by VS N. on 20 Nov 2019</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-separator"></span> </span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-seperator"></span> </span> </span> </div> <div class="yotpo-helpful"> <span class="y-label label-helpful">Was this review helpful?</span> <div class="yotpo-icon-btn-small transparent-color-btn vote-btn" data-type="up" role="button" aria-label="vote up Review by VS N. on 20 Nov 2019" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-thumbs-up"></span> </div> <span class="y-label yotpo-sum vote-sum" data-type="up">3</span> <div class="yotpo-icon-btn-small transparent-color-btn vote-btn" data-type="down" role="button" aria-label="vote down Review by VS N. on 20 Nov 2019" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-thumbs-down"></span> </div> <span class="y-label yotpo-sum vote-sum" data-type="down">0</span> </div> <div class="footer-additional-actions"> <span class="y-label yotpo-review-date">11/20/19</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-review yotpo-regular-box " data-review-id="132491816"> <div class="yotpo-header yotpo-verified-user "> <span class="yotpo-icon-profile yotpo-header-element pull-left"> <span class="yotpo-user-letter">J</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-circle-checkmark yotpo-action-hover" data-type="toggleFade" data-target="yotpo-tool-tip" data-target-container="yotpo-header"></span> </span> <div class="yotpo-header-element "> <span class="y-label yotpo-user-name yotpo-font-bold pull-left">John</span> <div class="label-with-tooltip pull-left"> <span class="y-label yotpo-user-title yotpo-action-hover" data-type="toggleFade" data-target="yotpo-tool-tip">Verified Reviewer</span> <div class="yotpo-tool-tip yotpo-animation-fade" data-user-type="yotpo-verified-user"> <div class="tool-tip-container"> <div class="x-button-for-touch-screens"><button class="pull-right" aria-label="Close"><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-cross"></span></button></div> <div class="tool-tip-header"> <span>What is a</span> <span class="header-blue">Verified Reviewer</span> </div> <div class="tool-tip-content"> A Verified Reviewer is a shopper who has confirmed an email address, or connected a social network with Yotpo, providing an added level of transparency and trust. </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <span class="yotpo-review-stars "> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="sr-only">5 star rating</span> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <div class="yotpo-user-related-fields"> <div class="yotpo-user-field" data-type=SingleChoice> <span class="yotpo-user-field-description text-s">Bottom Line:</span> <span class="yotpo-user-field-answer text-s">Yes</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </span> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-header-element yotpo-header-actions "> <span class="y-label yotpo-review-date">11/10/19</span> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-main "> <div class="yotpo-multiple-rating-fields"> <div class="yotpo-user-related-fields"> <div class="yotpo-user-field" data-type=SingleChoice> <span class="yotpo-user-field-description text-s">Bottom Line:</span> <span class="yotpo-user-field-answer text-s">Yes</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </div> <div class="content-title yotpo-font-bold"> Great casual shoe </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <div class="yotpo-review-wrapper"> <div class="content-review"> My wife gave me these shoes as a gift and I have been wearing them every weekend with jeans since. I have a wide foot and normally get a 11 2E in New Balance athletic shoes. In this shoe I needed a 10.5 wide and is very roomy in the toe box. My only recommendation for improvement is to make the gum sole a little more cushiony. I guess inserts may help with this. </div> </div> <a class="product-link-wrapper " aria-label="Product McGuffey Plain Toe" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1" href="https://yotpo.com/go/fNbuybH9" target="_blank" rel="nofollow"> <div data-product-id="118168366" class="y-label product-link"> On McGuffey Plain Toe </div> </a> </div> <div class="yotpo-footer "> <div class="footer-actions"> <span class="yotpo-action" data-type="toggleFade" data-target="share-review" aria-labelledby="review-132491816" role="button" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-share"></span> <span class="y-label">share</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-seperator"></span> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="review-132491816">' Share Review by John on 10 Nov 2019 </span> <span class="share-options-wrapper"> <span class="share-options share-review"> <span data-social="facebook"> <span class="y-label yotpo-action"> <a class="social-link popup-link" data-network="facebook" href="https://www.facebook.com/dialog/feed?app_id=226132034107547&aria_labelled_by=facebook-review-132491816&display=popup&link=http%3A%2F%2Freviews.me%2Ffacebook_post%3Fimage_url%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fcdn-yotpo-images-production.yotpo.com%252FProduct%252F118168366%252F94902388%252Ffacebook.jpg%253F1581189408%26product_url%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fyotpo.com%252Fgo%252FqfvqcdSn%26review%3DMy%2Bwife%2Bgave%2Bme%2Bthese%2Bshoes%2Bas%2Ba%2Bgift%2Band%2BI%2Bhave%2Bbeen%2Bwearing%2Bthem%2Bevery%2Bweekend%2Bwith%2Bjeans%2Bsince.%2BI%2Bhave%2Ba%2Bwide%2Bfoot%2Band%2Bnormally%2Bget%2Ba%2B11%2B2E%2Bin%2BNew%2BBalance%2Bathletic%2Bshoes.%2BIn%2Bthis%2Bshoe%2BI%2Bneeded%2Ba%2B10.5%2Bwide%2Band%2Bis%2Bvery%2Broomy%2Bin%2Bthe%2Btoe%2Bbox.%2BMy%2Bonly%2Brecommendation%2Bfor%2Bimprovement%2Bis%2Bto%2Bmake%2Bthe%2Bgum%2Bsole%2Ba%2Blittle%2Bmore%2Bcushiony.%2BI%2Bguess%2Binserts%2Bmay%2Bhelp%2Bwith%2Bthis.%26social_title%3DGreat%2Bcasual%2Bshoe&redirect_uri=http%3A%2F%2Fmy.yotpo.com%2Fshares%3Freview_id%3D132491816"><i class="facebook share" aria-labelledby="facebook-review-132491816">facebook</i></a> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="facebook-review-132491816">facebook Share Review by John on 10 Nov 2019</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-dot"></span> </span> <span data-social="twitter"> <span class="y-label yotpo-action"> <a class="social-link popup-link" data-network="twitter" href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?aria_labelled_by=twitter-review-132491816&text=My+wife+gave+me+these+shoes+as+a+gift+and+I+have+been+wearing+them+every+weekend+with+jeans+since.+I+have+a+wide+foot+and+normally+get+a+11+2E+in+New+Balance+athletic+shoes.+In+this+shoe+I+needed+a+10.5+wide+and+is+very+roomy+in+the+toe+box.+My+only+recommendation+for+improvement+is+to+make+the+gum+sole+a+little+more+cushiony.+I+guess+inserts+may+help+with+this.&url=https%3A%2F%2Fyotpo.com%2Fgo%2Fcs2QRYTq&via=yotpo"><i class="twitter share" aria-labelledby="twitter-review-132491816">twitter</i></a> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="twitter-review-132491816">twitter Share Review by John on 10 Nov 2019</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-dot"></span> </span> <span data-social="linkedin"> <span class="y-label yotpo-action"> <a class="social-link popup-link" data-network="LinkedIn" href="https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?aria_labelled_by=linkedin-review-132491816&mini=true&source=Yotpo&summary=My+wife+gave+me+these+shoes+as+a+gift+and+I+have+been+wearing+them+every+weekend+with+jeans+since.+I+have+a+wide+foot+and+normally+get+a+11+2E+in+New+Balance+athletic+shoes.+In+this+shoe+I+needed+a+10.5+wide+and+is+very+roomy+in+the+toe+box.+My+only+recommendation+for+improvement+is+to+make+the+gum+sole+a+little+more+cushiony.+I+guess+inserts+may+help+with+this.&title=Great+casual+shoe&url=https%3A%2F%2Fyotpo.com%2Fgo%2Fk7hKdLFh"><i class="LinkedIn share" aria-labelledby="linkedin-review-132491816">LinkedIn</i></a> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="linkedin-review-132491816">linkedin Share Review by John on 10 Nov 2019</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-separator"></span> </span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-seperator"></span> </span> </span> </div> <div class="yotpo-helpful"> <span class="y-label label-helpful">Was this review helpful?</span> <div class="yotpo-icon-btn-small transparent-color-btn vote-btn" data-type="up" role="button" aria-label="vote up Review by John on 10 Nov 2019" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-thumbs-up"></span> </div> <span class="y-label yotpo-sum vote-sum" data-type="up">4</span> <div class="yotpo-icon-btn-small transparent-color-btn vote-btn" data-type="down" role="button" aria-label="vote down Review by John on 10 Nov 2019" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-thumbs-down"></span> </div> <span class="y-label yotpo-sum vote-sum" data-type="down">0</span> </div> <div class="footer-additional-actions"> <span class="y-label yotpo-review-date">11/10/19</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-review yotpo-regular-box " data-review-id="125310823"> <div class="yotpo-header yotpo-verified-user "> <span class="yotpo-icon-profile yotpo-header-element pull-left"> <span class="yotpo-user-letter">R</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-circle-checkmark yotpo-action-hover" data-type="toggleFade" data-target="yotpo-tool-tip" data-target-container="yotpo-header"></span> </span> <div class="yotpo-header-element "> <span class="y-label yotpo-user-name yotpo-font-bold pull-left">Rob</span> <div class="label-with-tooltip pull-left"> <span class="y-label yotpo-user-title yotpo-action-hover" data-type="toggleFade" data-target="yotpo-tool-tip">Verified Reviewer</span> <div class="yotpo-tool-tip yotpo-animation-fade" data-user-type="yotpo-verified-user"> <div class="tool-tip-container"> <div class="x-button-for-touch-screens"><button class="pull-right" aria-label="Close"><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-cross"></span></button></div> <div class="tool-tip-header"> <span>What is a</span> <span class="header-blue">Verified Reviewer</span> </div> <div class="tool-tip-content"> A Verified Reviewer is a shopper who has confirmed an email address, or connected a social network with Yotpo, providing an added level of transparency and trust. </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <span class="yotpo-review-stars "> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-empty-star rating-star pull-left"></span><span class="sr-only">1 star rating</span> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <div class="yotpo-user-related-fields"> <div class="yotpo-user-field" data-type=SingleChoice> <span class="yotpo-user-field-description text-s">Bottom Line:</span> <span class="yotpo-user-field-answer text-s">No</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </span> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-header-element yotpo-header-actions "> <span class="y-label yotpo-review-date">09/16/19</span> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-main "> <div class="yotpo-multiple-rating-fields"> <div class="yotpo-user-related-fields"> <div class="yotpo-user-field" data-type=SingleChoice> <span class="yotpo-user-field-description text-s">Bottom Line:</span> <span class="yotpo-user-field-answer text-s">No</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </div> <div class="content-title yotpo-font-bold"> Not very comfortable </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> <div class="yotpo-review-wrapper"> <div class="content-review"> Worn a few times thinking they would break in but still hurt my feet. Also the rubber is coming apart. Not worth it. </div> </div> <a class="product-link-wrapper " aria-label="Product McGuffey Plain Toe" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1" href="https://yotpo.com/go/fNbuybH9" target="_blank" rel="nofollow"> <div data-product-id="118168366" class="y-label product-link"> On McGuffey Plain Toe </div> </a> </div> <div class="yotpo-footer "> <div class="footer-actions"> <span class="yotpo-action" data-type="toggleFade" data-target="share-review" aria-labelledby="review-125310823" role="button" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-share"></span> <span class="y-label">share</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-seperator"></span> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="review-125310823">' Share Review by Rob on 16 Sep 2019 </span> <span class="share-options-wrapper"> <span class="share-options share-review"> <span data-social="facebook"> <span class="y-label yotpo-action"> <a class="social-link popup-link" data-network="facebook" href="https://www.facebook.com/dialog/feed?app_id=226132034107547&aria_labelled_by=facebook-review-125310823&display=popup&link=http%3A%2F%2Freviews.me%2Ffacebook_post%3Fimage_url%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fcdn-yotpo-images-production.yotpo.com%252FProduct%252F118168366%252F94902388%252Ffacebook.jpg%253F1581189408%26product_url%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fyotpo.com%252Fgo%252FqfvqcdSn%26review%3DWorn%2Ba%2Bfew%2Btimes%2Bthinking%2Bthey%2Bwould%2Bbreak%2Bin%2Bbut%2Bstill%2Bhurt%2Bmy%2Bfeet.%2BAlso%2Bthe%2Brubber%2Bis%2Bcoming%2Bapart.%2BNot%2Bworth%2Bit.%26social_title%3DNot%2Bvery%2Bcomfortable&redirect_uri=http%3A%2F%2Fmy.yotpo.com%2Fshares%3Freview_id%3D125310823"><i class="facebook share" aria-labelledby="facebook-review-125310823">facebook</i></a> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="facebook-review-125310823">facebook Share Review by Rob on 16 Sep 2019</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-dot"></span> </span> <span data-social="twitter"> <span class="y-label yotpo-action"> <a class="social-link popup-link" data-network="twitter" href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?aria_labelled_by=twitter-review-125310823&text=Worn+a+few+times+thinking+they+would+break+in+but+still+hurt+my+feet.+Also+the+rubber+is+coming+apart.+Not+worth+it.&url=https%3A%2F%2Fyotpo.com%2Fgo%2Fcs2QRYTq&via=yotpo"><i class="twitter share" aria-labelledby="twitter-review-125310823">twitter</i></a> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="twitter-review-125310823">twitter Share Review by Rob on 16 Sep 2019</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-dot"></span> </span> <span data-social="linkedin"> <span class="y-label yotpo-action"> <a class="social-link popup-link" data-network="LinkedIn" href="https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?aria_labelled_by=linkedin-review-125310823&mini=true&source=Yotpo&summary=Worn+a+few+times+thinking+they+would+break+in+but+still+hurt+my+feet.+Also+the+rubber+is+coming+apart.+Not+worth+it.&title=Not+very+comfortable&url=https%3A%2F%2Fyotpo.com%2Fgo%2Fk7hKdLFh"><i class="LinkedIn share" aria-labelledby="linkedin-review-125310823">LinkedIn</i></a> </span> <span class="sr-only" id="linkedin-review-125310823">linkedin Share Review by Rob on 16 Sep 2019</span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-separator"></span> </span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-seperator"></span> </span> </span> </div> <div class="yotpo-helpful"> <span class="y-label label-helpful">Was this review helpful?</span> <div class="yotpo-icon-btn-small transparent-color-btn vote-btn" data-type="up" role="button" aria-label="vote up Review by Rob on 16 Sep 2019" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-thumbs-up"></span> </div> <span class="y-label yotpo-sum vote-sum" data-type="up">0</span> <div class="yotpo-icon-btn-small transparent-color-btn vote-btn" data-type="down" role="button" aria-label="vote down Review by Rob on 16 Sep 2019" tabindex="0"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-thumbs-down"></span> </div> <span class="y-label yotpo-sum vote-sum" data-type="down">0</span> </div> <div class="footer-additional-actions"> <span class="y-label yotpo-review-date">09/16/19</span> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-pager" data-total="307" data-per-page="5"> <a rel="prev" class="yotpo-page-element yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-left-arrow yotpo_previous yotpo-disabled" role="button" aria-label="Previous Page" tabindex="0"></a> <span class="yotpo-page-element goTo yotpo-active" data-page="1" role="button" aria-label="Page Number 1" tabindex="0">1</span> <span class="yotpo-page-element goTo " data-page="2" role="button" aria-label="Page Number 2" tabindex="0">2</span> <span class="yotpo-page-element goTo " data-page="3" role="button" aria-label="Page Number 3" tabindex="0">3</span> <span class="yotpo-page-element goTo yotpo-hidden-mobile" data-page="4" role="button" aria-label="Page Number 4" tabindex="0">4</span> <span class="yotpo-page-element goTo yotpo-hidden-mobile" data-page="5" role="button" aria-label="Page Number 5" tabindex="0">5</span> <span class="yotpo-page-element goTo yotpo-hidden-mobile" data-page="6" role="button" aria-label="Page Number 6" tabindex="0">6</span> <span class="yotpo-page-element goTo yotpo-hidden-mobile" data-page="7" role="button" aria-label="Page Number 7" tabindex="0">7</span> <span class="yotpo-page-element goTo yotpo-hidden-mobile" data-page="8" role="button" aria-label="Page Number 8" tabindex="0">8</span> <span class="yotpo-page-element goTo yotpo-hidden-mobile" data-page="9" role="button" aria-label="Page Number 9" tabindex="0">9</span> <a rel="next" class="yotpo-page-element yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-right-arrow yotpo_next " role="button" aria-label="Next Page" tabindex="0"></a> </div> <div class="yotpo yotpo-lightbox new"> <div class="yotpo-display-wrapper"> <div class="yotpo yotpo-modal"> <div class="yotpo-close-modal yotpo-icon-btn-small" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="Cancel"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-cross"></span> </div> <div class="yotpo-modal-mask"></div> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-container "> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-arrows"> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-left-arrow-thin" tabindex="0" role="button" aria-label="See Previous Image"></span> <span class="yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-right-arrow-thin" tabindex="0" role="button" aria-label="See Next Image"></span> </div> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-slider-container"> <div class="yotpo-modal-dialog"> <div class="yotpo-modal-content"> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-fade-container"> <div class="y-slider-container y-slide-left-animations"> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-image-container"> <img class="yotpo-lightbox-image" src="" data-media-type="image" alt="" tabindex="0"> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-mobile-content"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-image-container"> <img class="yotpo-lightbox-image" src="" data-media-type="image" alt="" tabindex="0"> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-mobile-content"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-image-container"> <img class="yotpo-lightbox-image" src="" data-media-type="image" alt="" tabindex="0"> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-mobile-content"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-image-container"> <img class="yotpo-lightbox-image" src="" data-media-type="image" alt="" tabindex="0"> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-mobile-content"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-image-container"> <img class="yotpo-lightbox-image" src="" data-media-type="image" alt="" tabindex="0"> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-mobile-content"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-image-container"> <img class="yotpo-lightbox-image" src="" data-media-type="image" alt="" tabindex="0"> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-mobile-content"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-image-container"> <img class="yotpo-lightbox-image" src="" data-media-type="image" alt="" tabindex="0"> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-mobile-content"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-image-container"> <img class="yotpo-lightbox-image" src="" data-media-type="image" alt="" tabindex="0"> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-mobile-content"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-image-container"> <img class="yotpo-lightbox-image" src="" data-media-type="image" alt="" tabindex="0"> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-mobile-content"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-image-container"> <img class="yotpo-lightbox-image" src="" data-media-type="image" alt="" tabindex="0"> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-mobile-content"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-image-container"> <img class="yotpo-lightbox-image" src="" data-media-type="image" alt="" tabindex="0"> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-mobile-content"></div> </div> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-image-container"> <img class="yotpo-lightbox-image" src="" data-media-type="image" alt="" tabindex="0"> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-mobile-content"></div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-image-loader-wrapper yotpo-hidden"> <div class="yotpo-image-loader">Loading...</div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="yotpo-lightbox-content-container"></div> <div class="yotpo-label yotpo-small-box "> <a href="http://my.yotpo.com/landing_page?redirect=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.yotpo.com%2Fpowered-by-yotpo%2F&utm_campaign=branding_link_reviews_widget_v2&utm_medium=widget&utm_source=johnstonmurphy.com" class="yotpo-logo-link-new" aria-label="Yotpo Home Page" tabindex="0" target="_blank"> <span class="yotpo-logo-title "> Powered by </span> <div class="yotpo-logo-bg-white yotpo-icon-btn-small yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-yotpo-logo-text yotpo-logo-icon-new yotpo-icon yotpo-icon-yotpo-logo "> </div> </a> <div class="yotpo-logo-line"> </div> <div class="yotpo-clr"></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div>